Question for this forum. I know there are dozens of ways to do the same things in computers and the world of packaging but what is the preferred method of running MSI's?

Assumption - your deployment tools is SMS/SCCM

A. When you have a MSI you always use a .MST to perform all custom actions. (run a custom action that does post install settings as an example)

B. Wrap your MSI in a tool like Wise Script Editor which runs your MSI and then does any post config steps you need done?

C. A combo of both?

0 Comments   [ + ] Show Comments


Please log in to comment

Rating comments in this legacy AppDeploy message board thread won't reorder them,
so that the conversation will remain readable.


Our preferred method is MSI. We transform Vendor MSI's, and deploy only MSI.
If I have a need to create a Wise Script it would be wrapped in an MSI.
Answered 12/06/2010 by: reds4eva
Second Degree Blue Belt

Please log in to comment
I avoid WiseScript like the plague, on the basis that anything that can't be done in an MSI can be done by a much more widely used and supported scripting technology, VBScript.

For example: find some WiseScript which correctly handles the installation of Excel add-ins. Now find some VBScript. I probably only need the fingers of one hand to count the number of hits for the former...
Answered 12/07/2010 by: VBScab
Red Belt

Please log in to comment
Thanks for your feedback VBScab and since you seem to know a lot of good stuff may I ask you another question? Doing Bing and Google searches for MSI & MST info returns tons of info that is a pita to sift through. Do you have a doc that clearly illustrates how/where to place your Custom Actions in a .MST to do pre & post tweaks to your machine? Here is exactly what I mean.

We all get stuck in our ways (at least I do) and what I've done for years is this. I wrap everything in a Wise Script (.wse file) and compile it into an .EXE. In this wise script I can do any pre-game work I need (i.e. uninstall an old version of software, clean up desktop icons etc...etc....). Then I run my .EXE or .MSI/.MST to install the new software. Then, I can do my post-game config. Run an Excel macro, tweak the regisry, add custom desktop icons etc...etc...

So if you have a link to a site that shows how/when/where to trigger custom actions to handle pre & post tweaks that would be great.
Thank you for your time and help.
Answered 12/07/2010 by: mhsl808
Fifth Degree Brown Belt

Please log in to comment
Answer this question or Comment on this question for clarity