Free or Demo MSI Packagers
Are there any Free or Demo MSI packagers? I know the Veritas Winstall from the Windows 2000 CD, but are there any others? I have the Computer Associates Software Packager, but I can not get the converted MSI files to run on machines without the CA Agent installed.
0 Comments
[ + ] Show comments
Answers (13)
Please log in to answer
Posted by:
aogilmor
16 years ago
I would say if it doesn't run without an agent it is not Windows Installer standard. Check and see if the package has launch conditions in it. CA might do that in their packaging template or something. Maybe you can set up the template not to do that. Even if you want to integrate tightly with the CA back end I don't think it's a good idea to have that dependency in the MSI, as it limits your flexibility and it really is not standard.
As for free or demo, all the vendors have demo versions of their products with some limited functionality or timeout period.
As for free or demo, all the vendors have demo versions of their products with some limited functionality or timeout period.
Posted by:
madsquirrel21
16 years ago
Posted by:
jmcfadyen
16 years ago
Posted by:
anonymous_9363
16 years ago
Is it me?!?
A Google for 'freeware +msi +create' produced enough hits to keep you busy. I used Advanced Installer (the first hit) a few years back when I dipped my toe into MSI for a stingy client who didn't want to spring for the proper tools.
You would want to avoid creating an MSI from scratch in Orca unless you are a *complete* propeller-head (no offense to anyone...)
A Google for 'freeware +msi +create' produced enough hits to keep you busy. I used Advanced Installer (the first hit) a few years back when I dipped my toe into MSI for a stingy client who didn't want to spring for the proper tools.
You would want to avoid creating an MSI from scratch in Orca unless you are a *complete* propeller-head (no offense to anyone...)
Posted by:
AngelD
16 years ago
You would want to avoid creating an MSI from scratch in Orca unless you are a *complete* propeller-head (no offense to anyone...)
Well if you know what you're doing there shouldn't be any problem creating clean MSIs using ORCA thus WiX has a nice XML structure which in the end is the same as using ORCA. ORCA is a nice tool and in combined with ex. vbscript it shouldn't take that long time to create a smaller package. I wouldn't use ORCA to create big once though.
Posted by:
aogilmor
16 years ago
ORIGINAL: madsquirrel21
This is what CA support told me..."The MSI created via the packager is more of an emulation wrapper of an MSI rather than a true MSI, therefore it needs an SDO agent installed."
This is not what I wanted to hear, but oh well. I have used ORCA to edit but never create. I will check it out.
Thanks
Yeah, that seems like a strange reply. I wonder if they even know the difference between MSI and non-MSI installations. I'd like to see the "emulation" (as they put it) and see if it really creates a MSI file. Installshield installations, for example, often contain references and custom actions with installshield binaries and so forth, will wrap everything in an EXE file and will try to prevent you from running the MSI without them. But if you dissect the MSI with Orca or Wise you can often take out the offending proprietary parts so you can run the plain MSI or use a transform - with varying levels of difficulty depending on the installation.
Also, IMHO, any vendor that creates non-MSI installations for Windows is out of their mind. setup.exe and script installations are going the way of batch files. Actually probably not even that since some batch files will still be useful...[:D]
Posted by:
madsquirrel21
16 years ago
Posted by:
AngelD
16 years ago
Posted by:
anonymous_9363
16 years ago
Posted by:
AngelD
16 years ago
Posted by:
kkaminsk
16 years ago
Posted by:
AngelD
16 years ago
Rating comments in this legacy AppDeploy message board thread won't reorder them,
so that the conversation will remain readable.
so that the conversation will remain readable.